Most likely it is because of an open clubface; rarely have i have someone with decent clubface control have problems with axis tilt through the ball. From memory you fight an OTT move and fades yes?
open clubface as in what? I don't understand this. Do you mean open club face from the top or you open it when you take away, or you open it on the downswing? What does it apply when you say open clubface?
I still have no idea why he wants to start his downswing with his right shoulder going down. Its not for everybody. I'd be a 10 handicap if I did that.
At what point do you think maybe that isnt the issue?
Sorry Kevin you lost me.....what isn't the issue?....