New: MARCH '04 - Rolling The Rock

Status
Not open for further replies.

Brian Manzella

Administrator
Rolling the rock.

When I give putting lessons-which golfers take far too few of-it amazes me how little golfers know about what the putter should do during the putting stroke. Regardless of how you grip it, or how you stand to it, the putter should do five very important things.

Solid contact is the most important element. The middle of the putter face should contact the middle of the ball (or slightly above the middle). 99.9% of all putters on the market today are what are called 'low-profile' putters. What this means is that the putter face height is lower than the height of the ball. By a lot.
(PIC 1)
marchpic1.jpg

That means that for the middle of the putter face to contact the middle of the ball, the putter head MUST be raised at impact.

There are two options for this to occur. You either have to pull inward with your arms or elbows during the stroke or you can start with the putter at the proper height. As radical as the latter seems, it is employed by two current Champions Tour players who had some outstanding success as golfers (and putters): Jay Sigel and Don Pooley.

A good way to practice this is to place four quarters on the ground behind the ball.
(PIC 2)
marchpic2.jpg

Either address the ball by hovering the putter slightly above the quarters or by placing the putter on the ground behind the quarters. Then make your stroke, hitting the ball without contacting the quarters.

Getting the putter the right height at impact is all for naught if the putter shaft is not leaning slightly forward at impact. If you have the shaft vertical at impact you had better have a putter with next to no loft on it to get the solid strike we are seeking. If the putter shaft is leaning backward and the putter head is on the 'upswing' at impact, the middle of the face will miss the middle of the ball by a lot.
(PIC 3)
marchpic3.jpg

The proper application is slight forward lean of the shaft at impact (PIC 2).

These first two important elements-forward leaning shaft and center or above contact on the ball-are interestingly nearly always present on the most nonchalant of putting strokes: the 'rake-in.' You know, when you have missed your putt slightly wide and long and you reach the putter out (usually with one arm) and rake/stroke the ball in the hole. It always amazed me how many of these 'putts' go in as compared to the 'knuckle-down' two to three footer that meant something. But it is obvious why this is in the context of what we have just discussed on ideal contact.

The 'rake-in' impact
(PIC 4)
marchpic4.jpg

contacts the ball above center with forward lean where the 'knuckle-down' putt that is 'yipped' and missed is often contacted below center with the clubshaft 'laying back' (PIC 3).

The third must is for the 'path' of the stroke to be 'on-plane.' There are two camps of putting paths these days. Camp one lead by Dave Pelz believes the putter head should travel straight back and straight through during the stroke. Pelz and others have been the dominant 'authorities' with this methodology for nearly 20 years. The other camp teaches that the putter should make a curved path that swings back to the inside, returns to the ball and then swings through to the inside. This camp is led by new putting 'guru' Stan Utley. I have long known that this is the most effective stroke, because the shaft is on an incline at address and it should swing back and through on this incline just like any other golf stroke chip to full drive.

There are many new devices that are on the market to assist you in making a curved stroke with your putter, but a simple understanding of why the putter head curves to the starting line of the putt will allow you to construct a homemade training aid for this type of stroke in a few seconds.

If the putter (or any other club) rests on an imaginary inclined plane, like a roof, and the ball is in the gutter, the putter will swing back --up the roof--- to the inside of the gutter-line. As it returns to the ball it will get back on that line and through the ball again swing up the roof and inside the gutter.
So an overhead view of this 'path' would show the putter making a curved path.

To practice this on-plane motion, simply find a flat board and rest the putter head against the board at address. Place the ball opposite the 'sweetspot' of the putter. This sweetspot is the small area on the face that if the ball is struck on the face will not twist. You can test for this spot by holding the putter in the air at the grip with two fingers and tapping the putter head with your finger until the 'no-twist- spot is found.
(PIC 5)
marchpic5.jpg

Hitting the ball on this no-twist area is the fourth key element to great putting.

The on-plane stroke is made by lightly scraping the heel of the putter against the 'plane board.'
(PIC 6)
marchpic6.jpg

Your putter will make the perfect curved path every time. Practice makes permanent.

The final must is to have the face of the putter perpendicular to the plane at all times during the stroke. If your puter has a 'square' heel area, make sure this stays completely on the board (PIC 6). This will assure that when the ball leaves the putter (when the shaft is vertical) the ball will travel perfectly on the intended line.

Combined with the perfect contact of the middle of the putter face contact the middle (or slightly higher) of the ball with a forward leaning shaft on the sweetspot, and you will 'roll-the-rock' with the best of them.[8D]
 
Enjoyed the article Brian.

Could you please explain how you would like the golfer to set up so that he/she can perform the actions you describe ie do we set up with a flat left wrist and tilted shoulders? Thanks.
 
nice article,as usual I have learned more about the golf swing from Brian's articles than everything else I've read in the last 20yrs.
Thanks, Brian for sharing your knowledge.
 
Thanks for setting the record straight for all those that think the ball is putted on the upswing! Great, simply great article.
 
The straight-back-straight thru method of putting (Pelz) can not work because the USGA requires putters to have a shaft lie angle with a minimum of ten degrees of diverge from vertical. If the shaft putter was vertical, the story might be different (croquet). Ben Crenshaw, known as a player that uses and extreme inside to square to inside path has a putter with a flatter than standard lie angle (one of the reasons his eye line is set inside his target line at address). Players with a more upright lie angle have less inside to inside stroke, but must still move on an incline plane. Great article.
 
Wouldnt a shorter putter shaft and possibly a flatter lie angle cure some of common woes?

What I am getting at, is that the combo of above, would get the Toe of the putter in the air helping correct area of contact, without having to "lift" the putter---which adds tension in my mind

Caught an article somewhere that most golfers use much too long putters, which forces elbow bend, setup problems, too low contact etc

thanks for input
 

hue

New
Brian : I know your opinions on who the best full swing coaches are. Who are the best putting coaches out there in your opinion ? Toms is a very good putter who taught him this aspect of the game? Thanks.
 
quote:Originally posted by Worm

The "plane board" should match the angle of the shaft, correct?

I think it should match the plane you desire to swing on.....turned shoulder, elbow etc...
 
Very informative article. May I say, even revolutionary. Everything I have read or seen about putting states to keep the putterhead straight down the target line. Any time they have an instructor on the Golf Channel talking about putting,they use the same drill....2 clubs parallel along the target line spaced apart the length of the putter head, then sweep the putterhead down the target line and don't hit either of the clubs. No mention of arcs or planes. Gotta digest this article some more.
 
I read from the other forum with this kind of putting:

Open stance, open shoulder line, use right arm as the only power source, zero out all others, flat left wrist all along, hit the ball and then both arm straight. I try that and the distance control is much better, the open stance give you a clear view and allow the left arm, putting stroke to go straight to the target. Is this a good way to putt?

I also watch Bobby's tape on putting and he recommended a left hand low, top of the grip few inches above the left hand, right hand on top of the left hand, shoulder as the power source. However, I found the shoulder as the power source more difficult for distance control, after impact the right arm not straight. The above stroke with right arm striaght is more TGM and easier to apply.
 

EdZ

New
Another imporant note on the motion of the putter...

the concept of 'releasing' the putter is KEY to consistent speed and direction control. As Brian mentioned, the putter is on an arc - you can either 'block' your putts (Pelz - although there are other variables, shoulder position) or 'release'/'hook' your putts (Utley, Manzilla, Locke,EdZ ;)

Now of course you don't actually put hook spin on the ball, but you DO want to feel as if the toe turns over - you will notice a BIG difference in your distance control

So if you are to error to one side or the other, block vs. hook - you will do well to feel more 'hook'.

There was an old timer at Harding Park when I was growing up that putted with a completely closed/hooded traditional blade putter, probably the best putter I've seen. A quick try of that approach will show you how much better the ball will roll with that 'release' of the toe of the putter - same idea Brian shows in the 'rake in' - FAR better roll to the ball.....

Add some C-grooves, understanding break vs. aim, and start collecting the bets!

Another addition.... when it comes to putting, read Brian's "don't hit it at the target article again" - inside back corner, slightly open clubface still applies, just to a lesser degree..
 
I actually found that the looking at the inside back corner of the ball/mind in the hands method, works great with putts too.
Brian - you recommend putting with the ball forward in the stance, same position as iron shots, right.
 
in the book, we have 2-C-4 that shows what Brian illustrates about the downstroke in putting...the top pic (about vertical shaft with middle of head to middle of ball) would be a "skidding at first" kinda roll...
the second would be a Brians forward leaning shaft striking over center of ball contact that gives an overspin and makes "ball stick too surface" kinda roll...
and least and least desired would be a "hopping first" (leaning back shaft striking under center of ball)kinda stroke...dead ball...would this be correct?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top