Who are yours, and does today move Phil onto your list?
It is not a one week tournament....Tiger would win and Johnny Miller would finish second.
Its a career.
How many of these players have won 3 out of 4 majors and finished in the U.S.open second place 5 or 6 times(I forgot) . I do agree with your list but Phil must be considered.
I have said this before, so what's one more time....
I saw Nelson at 60, Snead at 70 and didn't see Hogan.
I saw everyone else on any list hit balls live.
Johnny Miller is the best I ever saw.
Everyone acknowledges Phil's brilliance. That final round was just spectacular. Maybe that was the greatest round of golf I've witnessed (I am 34). Especially the last 4 or 5 holes. You couldn't root against him during that stretch.