YES, I'd call that a BAD case of timing the flip.
What's wrong with it?
Well, there might not be ANYTHING wrong with the PARTICULAR shot that he just hit. But go play golf with this guy for 4 or 5 rounds, and make sure there's someone in your foursome for those rounds who does NOT flip it.
Then observe the following:
- the flipper's scores are all over the map compared to the non-flipper, even if they have similar handicaps
- the flipper is more likely to hit a hideous shot than the non-flipper
- given similar size and swing type, the non-flipper hits it further
- the flipper panics when he has a bad lie while the non-flipper just hits down on it with his pivot
If none of that convinces you, then just LISTEN to the flipper hit the ball, and then LISTEN to a pro hit the ball. The flipper's shot probably sounds like every average amateur golfer's shot; but listen to a pro hit a 7 iron and it sounds like a gun went off.
As everyone has said before, you can play scratch golf with a flip, so you may not want to worry about it. Part of it depends on what your goals are.
Do you want to play golf under pressure (even if only in friendly local tournaments)? If so, I HIGHLY recommend a swing without a flip. And this is especially true if you can't play every day. Flippers rely on timing and their swings are more easily exposed by lay-offs and by the pressure of competition.