If the lead arm runs out if its socket on the backswing it seems that this would lead to a tug on the downswing to rectify.
Is this just a self-evident truism or, as I suspect, are there other forces at play?
Guys that do that are using their lead arm deltoid to swing that arm up on the backswing. Halfway back the anterior deltoid goes to max contraction and in order to keep swinging up, the arm has to move away from the body. Then it is out there all by it's lonesome and you have to lasso it back in, or in order to keep slack out of the system, you just tug or pull it down.....and out. Don't do that.
Relax the lead arm deltoids, and use the trail arm to swing the lead arm up and across the chest.
Guys that do that are using their lead arm deltoid to swing that arm up on the backswing. Halfway back the anterior deltoid goes to max contraction and in order to keep swinging up, the arm has to move away from the body. Then it is out there all by it's lonesome and you have to lasso it back in, or in order to keep slack out of the system, you just tug or pull it down.....and out. Don't do that.
Relax the lead arm deltoids, and use the trail arm to swing the lead arm up and across the chest.
Guys, just drop the club. Grab your left wrist with your right hand and make a pretend backswing. That's how you do it. Left arm is relaxed and acts as a spacer for the radius only.
Tried this at the range today. Felt crazy weird.
Brian illustrated it well:Guys, just drop the club. Grab your left wrist with your right hand and make a pretend backswing. That's how you do it. Left arm is relaxed and acts as a spacer for the radius only.
Here is what folks call the "Geometry of The Circle":
![]()
I have often said that it is a VERY inaccurate representation of the golf swing.
It is.
Below is one I did this morning for fun.
Only one problem, it isn't correct either.
The center of the shoulder turn (middle of the balck circle) MOVES in a real swing.
The uncocking of BOTH WRISTS (and the right one is uncocking faster that the left one!) are causing the club to make more of an inward move.
The left arm can bend and rotate all sorts of ways.
The clubshaft bows downward, lags and leads.
Etc, etc, etc!!!
But....have a look:
![]()
![]()
A little bit of crazy weird is good sometimes.
Guys, just drop the club. Grab your left wrist with your right hand and make a pretend backswing. That's how you do it. Left arm is relaxed and acts as a spacer for the radius only.
You know, I've been trying to separate the pelvic turn from the torso in the transition for the longest time by focusing on the pelvis and torso. Doing as you say in the backswing with the right arm seems to make it much easier to separate. I have always felt better with the swing feeling like a right arm throwing motion and this makes it even mo' better. Thanks Virtand thanks to OLIVER for starting the thread.
It is true that good players go back wide and down narrower, but they do it in a totally different way. It is sequence related: the unwind takes place closer to the ball than the wind-up did going back. That is why it is narrower on the downswing.