I know it's dangerous to write off Tiger as he has often proven otherwise but I fear he has changed his swing once too often,has spent all his quota of 15 foot putts that matter and his almost perfect record of winning tournaments while leading on Sunday has gotta start evening out.His odds are against him.If he does break Jack's record he'll do it limping over the line.
I think you bring up a good point. I look at Tiger a bit like I feel about Moe Norman. Hearing Moe talk and listening to guys who played tournaments with Moe, one could see why he could shoot incredible rounds and hit incredible shots and why he couldn't achieve greatness outside of the Canadian Tour. Yes, Moe had anti-social behavior, but if you listened to Moe talk, he was all about going for the gusto. He didn't play with fear on the course. He talked about if you're -3 after 14 how everybody talks about 'hope I can hang on to break par' and he would say 'birdie the last 4 and shoot a 65.' I think Moe had to have that type of attitude to shoot 59 as often as he did and to hit those incredible shots he did. I'm fairly aggressive on the course and fairly confident compared to most golfers, even those of my caliber, but I don't think I could ever quite achieve Moe's fearlessness and confidence and that's why I think even if I had Moe's mechanics and coordination, I still wouldn't hit the ball nearly as great as he did. Now, I might be able to achieve great success on the PGA Tour, but to be the guy that everybody stops to watch on the range is a different story.
With Tiger, it's a similar attitude. Believing that he can outplay what he did in 2000. I don't know if I could truly believe that, particularly his win at Pebble Beach. To me, that's about the highest level of golf one can play outside of Johnny Miller's 63 at Oakmont. But that's probably what makes Tiger great whereas if I had Tiger's skill and ability, I'd likely be just very good.
I do feel for Tiger a bit. He went with Haney and IMO, he did 6-7 years worth of damage to his game. Yes, he won a ton and won a lot of majors, but that's because he developed into a great putter and a great overall short game. If he had better instruction, he could've won more and smashed records. Now he's got to get himself out of the Haney stuff and that takes time. It also takes away time he could spend on putting. And then even if you get it down, it takes time to fully trust it.
3JACK