As a long-time consumer of everything golf, there are few things that make me want to run from a room faster than someone who wants to sell me "the secret." And if "the secret" is packaged along with the names of Moe Norman, Mike Austin, or Ben Hogan, I run from the room even faster. At least with Ben Hogan, you can sort of understand the fascination. He won a lot of big tournaments, and maybe he developed a particularly good pattern we should examine closely.
Ok, Moe Norman was a good ballstriker and his swing looked a little different than some, even if it was partly a little posing and styling or a personal flourish or two. Ok, Mike Austin was a very long hitter, I believe that. His swing looks like a powerful swing.
But please, please, please spare me ANY stories of 515 yard drives at a tournament in the desert in 1969 or the super secret hidden secrets of golf. Add some really blurry video from the '60s, and I get the feeling we're stalking the Bigfoot of golf. You might as well be selling x-ray vision eyeglasses and live seahorses in the back of Mad Magazine when you sink to that level.
So why worship a long driver or good ballstriker of 30-40-50 years ago (especially if they never won 4-5 major championships)? Does anyone really think they knew something about good ballstriking or long driving had some super-secret that the current golfers don't (intuitively) know or use? I totally disbelieve that.
Someone can prove me wrong.
In fact, PLEASE prove me wrong by stating in 150 words and in plain english something that some holder of some ancient golf secret did then that golfers who hit it good or long now don't do today. In fact, I'll settle for a description of one distinctive element in the Norman or Austin method that is distinctive and couldn't be discerned from studying golfers of today. Just one. Give me a single logical reason to look at Austin or Norman (who seem to have developed more of a cult following than anyone but Hogan) and think they had something no one since has had.
Personally for me, as the jaded golf consumer, someone can have a very effective and very useful teaching aid, but they taint it by associating it with the concept of ancient secrets and the ancient mystics of golf.