Lag - Left Arm Reference Point

Status
Not open for further replies.
Jwat,

I have always enjoyed your presence on this forum.

Everyone, as you've just written above, keeps calling this new information about the release- "early release". It has nothing to do "early", but more to do with " correct".

By looking at these "stills" one thing jumps out at me. I see a ton of pivot and little arm swing. Look at how little your arms have lowered and how much you pivot has turned/moved. I am not one to use scientific vernacular, but you are putting so little pressure into the area where you want to see lag.

If there is one thing that has to happen in great golf swings it is that YOUR ARMS HAVE TO SWING.
 
Oh and by the way, the best piece of advice I have ever received in golf instruction ( I have had a lot and from many of the best) is SWING YOUR ARMS.
 
Lindsey, in the aftermath video Brian talks about "tumble torque" while staying on plane and replacing the lead arm. Could this be a key ingredient missing in people with throw away?
 

Kevin Shields

Super Moderator
Kevin,

For guys like me who have zero lag or right wrist angle, shouldn't we learn to get lag at some point in the swing? It has been said several time that the release isn't for everyone, would you consider me on the side which absolutely doesn't need to focus on early release?

I understand how lining it up and less tugging will get my path on more of a leftward plane, but it feels like it has killed my club head speed and not really made me any more consistent at impact. So would guys like me and gmbtempe benefit less from the early release? I just think at some point to get consistent and pick back up the distance I lost this year, I am going to have to learn to be more open at impact with a little more lag at some point in the downswing.

BTW, I read a tip you had told someone from 2008 from BManz where he said "No axis tilt until after the sit on the DS". This has really helped me from getting so far out in front of the ball.

photo1.png

photo2.png


photo3.png




photo4.png

Whoever said to focus on an early release?????
 

Kevin Shields

Super Moderator
Lindsey, in the aftermath video Brian talks about "tumble torque" while staying on plane and replacing the lead arm. Could this be a key ingredient missing in people with throw away?

I only wish I could be Lindsey, but in a word, yes. Throwaway, is always the lead arm and almost never early tumble. Backed up shafts, as the big man likes to call it.
 
Oh and by the way, the best piece of advice I have ever received in golf instruction ( I have had a lot and from many of the best) is SWING YOUR ARMS.

+1,000

Got "swing" and "arms" tatooed on the inside of my eye lids so when I start my down swing I can see them.
 

Kevin Shields

Super Moderator
Oh and by the way, the best piece of advice I have ever received in golf instruction ( I have had a lot and from many of the best) is SWING YOUR ARMS.

You could run into a lot of trouble delaying arm swing for any length of time in the downswing. A lot of gofers that look like they immediately throw it away are still trying to catch p to run away pivots or incomplete turns.
 
There is indeed a lot of pivot in those first few iPhone images...I could see how that could tug on the left arm and release the club earlier than intended.

More arm swing/less pivot in the first part of the swing pretty much equates to keeping your back turned to the target I think? Should get more 'lag' halfway down then.
 
Todd - I know you're a big fan of Cochran & Stubbs. So, what are your thoughts on measuring lag the way you describe, using the left arm as a proxy for the upper lever, rather than a line from somewhere in the hand-wrist area to the sternum (which is where C&S located their "swing centre" - albeit one that moved)?

Also, where would you draw your upper lever relative to Westwood's bent left arm?

Yeah, I prefer to use the left arm as the upper lever. Surprising that "Search" didn't do the same, considering how they pointed out that the basic and essential swing is with the left arm.

The upper lever, again, is drawn from the shoulder to the point on the grip where the hands join. When you do it this way, you realize that even guys like Westwood, Goosen, and Sadlowski still have the shaft behind the upper lever at impact.
 
Yes but since a golf swing is not 2D, lag shouldn't be measured using this model. The lag that a real golfer uses is the lag behind the right wrist, even though you are certainly correct that it doesn't pass the left arm, save for perhaps guys like Westwood

The discourse here results from a difference in definition of "lag". You seem to be defining it as measurement of "unseen forces". Fine. I'm simply defining it as the angle between the rods of a double pendulum. This angle at impact is as much about achieving an optimal Attack Angle and Dynamic Loft as it is an indicator of good force/leverage.
 

jimmyt

New
I really feel that a lot of people still do not understand that the appearance of lag in a 2d pic is a useless way to confirm if someone has lag or not.

A golfer definitely does not want to "hold" anything. The idea is to get the clubhead to line up with as much speed as desired for the given shot. Chasing a certain "look" on video isn't playing golf it's chasing your tail.




+3 Great Post, should go in the Hall of Fame, seriously
 

jimmyt

New
Since the chief misfit apparently still copies and pastes everything from here, he should read Greg's post. You need lag, you just don't hold it. Anyone who can do it should know this. They love to giggle at things like "out toss" and other things they don't understand, but they are all put in to delay the fleeing out of the club and preserve lag, or whatever, later in the downswing.

But he won't paste this on his ridiculous site because he wouldn't have anything to rip on.



You hang in there Kevin, you are holding your own.......and I love it.
 

Jwat

New
Jwat,

I have always enjoyed your presence on this forum.

Everyone, as you've just written above, keeps calling this new information about the release- "early release". It has nothing to do "early", but more to do with " correct".

By looking at these "stills" one thing jumps out at me. I see a ton of pivot and little arm swing. Look at how little your arms have lowered and how much you pivot has turned/moved. I am not one to use scientific vernacular, but you are putting so little pressure into the area where you want to see lag.

If there is one thing that has to happen in great golf swings it is that YOUR ARMS HAVE TO SWING.

Hey Lindsey,

I guess I am using the wrong terminology when it comes to stating the release as being early. Although, during my lesson a couple months ago, BManz was having me out toss immediately and focus on putting the left hand on the wall and that was the main focus of the lesson. I feel like I have gotten the left hand on the wall down to a T, but still lacking the consistent impact.

I think you are definitely right about the no arms on the DS. I have worked really hard the last 3 years getting a good pivot on the BS that I have allowed it to leak into the DS and the arms have been left behind.

I know we aren't supposed to be focusing on holding lag and what not. But, I have never had any lag to try to hold or retain ever in the DS. I believe that alot of guys do need less drag/hold, but my question is, "Do I personally need to be focusing on out tossing early in the swing?"

Whoever said to focus on an early release?????

Yea I was using the wrong terminology. I was told to out toss immediately where the face of the club is pointing to the sky and finish with my left hand on the wall. And I think that is great for alot of guys. And I have worked hard on it non stop for a couple of months now.


photo-1.png



But it just seems like it isn't working and I have more throwaway now and definitely have lost even more distance. So I am just trying to figure out, "is this what is best for my swing?" I have a vested interest in changing my swing for the good and not just keep implementing short term fixes. I just dont see any good ball strikers whether it be the scratch guys I play with or tour pros that are ever in this position on the DS.



photo3.png




There is indeed a lot of pivot in those first few iPhone images...I could see how that could tug on the left arm and release the club earlier than intended.

More arm swing/less pivot in the first part of the swing pretty much equates to keeping your back turned to the target I think? Should get more 'lag' halfway down then.

I agree, looks like alot of pivot, but what good scratch player doesn't have alot of pivot on the BS. Believe me, during my lesson I was focusing less on pivot and just trying to get the back to the target and I hit the ball straightish. But when I do that I am at least 1-2 irons shorter and 20 yds shorter with the driver. I am already struggling with a huge power leak that I have been dealing with this year where I have already lost those yardages with all my clubs.

So if I make a swing without a good pivot and just get my back to the target, we are talking about me being every bit of 2 irons shorter and 30-40 yds less with my driver from where I was at last year. I just don't feel like it is a good tradeoff.

Jwat, Here is what I've been doing to eliminate my throw away and learn how to tumble:

1. Watch the Alexander Noren drill Kevin posted on xmas eve 100 times and pay attention to what he is doing.

2. Watch the aftermath video between the 10-13 minute mark and see kind of how Brian incorporates that into staying on plane and replacing the lead arm. (this was a major light bulb moment for me, man was I doing it wrong)

3. Read Lindsey's posts on the Sergio Tumble thread on page 9 and 10. It is much easier to understand what the hell he talking about after doing #1 & #2.

Hey Jeremy, thanks for the reply:

1. I have worked on this drill some and it definitely promotes less tug no doubt about it. But for me it is only successful with my 6i-wedge. When I do this drill before swinging midiron +, I hit really skanky shots in the heel of the club.
2. I will re watch this part of the video to see what you are pointing out.
3. I have read that thread over and over always pickup a new nugget from Lindsey and Kevin's posts. So I will go back to those pages and see if I can apply any of it.


All in all, I am just frustrated now that I have been taking lessons and participating on the board for 3 years now and still haven't accomplished any goals I set for myself. I bet I have flown to New Orleans at least 7 times over the past 3 years. To see guys go day in and day out hitting the ball solid and consistent and have half the knowledge and golf ability I have is very frustrating to say the least. I am a 3 hcp for 1 reason and only 1 reason and that is ball striking. I chip, putt, and manage the course like a scratch golfer but hit the ball like a 8 hcp. And to top it off, I have lost so much distance this year in every club its made it that much harder. I appreciate everyone's participation with my swing.

Alot of us spend countless hours learning about the golf swing, but if we can't apply it to our own swing than what is the point?
 
Last edited:
Jwat,

I think the comments related to "back to the target" have to do with keeping your back to the target longer on the downswing while the arms get swinging. Brian mentioned in one of his recent "how to" posts that from the top of the backswing you should allow your arms to drop so that the clubhead is 20 to 30 inches from the ball whille essentially keeping your back facing the target in the first part of the downswing. Have you tried that drill?

It's hard to get the arms "swinging" if they move 1-for-1 with the pivot.
 
1. Can you have forward shaft lean without some lag at impact?

2. If not, wouldn't dynamic loft be an indicator of lag?

3. If so, then wouldn't spin loft be an indicator of the effectiveness of said lag?

4. If yes, then wouldn't the increased compression (compression = spin loft) be the only benefit of lag at impact?

5. Consiquently, wouldn't the only honest way to measure lag be with a LM?



If the answer to any of these is "No"... please disregard the next question(s).

Mike,

After watching the first ASII video, especially the stuff on clubhead lead/lag, I wonder if conditions like "forward shaft lean at impact" have any meaning, i.e. any effect on spin loft.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top