I read this thread from the beginning, and I never took it as "The D-Plane may be wrong" thread, but more as a "There will likely be more detailed information about the intricacies of the D-Plane to surface, such as considerations for off-centre hits" thread.
That was my interpretation. I don't think you two are disagreeing on much, if anything, really.
does my clock face theory hold water?
If so, what does the horizontal 3-9 axis orient itself about?
Screw the glee, lets get to the goods.
Here it first.
I am only interested.