People need to drop this arguement already, i respect your opinion that you feel it was better. However Hogan HIMSELF felt that his power golf version was the best he ever hit it.
So essentially you are disagreeing with the own man's opinion, which again is fine, but drop it already.
You need to get your facts straight. Hogan said on several occasions in the '50's (following victories at the Masters and US Open) that he was hitting it better than ever. You can look it up. Middlecoff observed first hand that Hogan hit the ball better in 1950 than in 1948. You can look that up, too. Herbert Warren Wind reported the same thing in the '50's. Were Hogan, Wind and Middlecoff lying? Don't think so.
I've seen the interview where Hogan talks wistfully about his late '48/early '49
GOLF GAME, not
BALLSTRIKING, and I can understand why: Hogan dominated the tour in the late '40's, and his winning percentage in the
non-majors went down dramatically after the accident, even though his winning percentage in the
majors skyrocketed. But, as I hope we all know, ballstriking alone doesn't win tour events. And, when you stop holing putts, it won't win majors, either.