Brian Manzella for Golf Magazine, Golf.com & FRONT9 - Tiger's Hand Move with Irons

Status
Not open for further replies.

Brian Manzella

Administrator
From that angle its very hard to see with the left wrist is doing, I see it rotating more than anything until its well past impact.

You can do it.....

Let go, Greg, let go.

It will be alllllllright.

Tiger does it....trust me, you idolize the guy I put the graph up of.

We won't hammer you too bad when you realize we were right.
 
No.


This is a very respected teacher outside of our group who has capture many PGA Tour players on his AMM/12 sensor system.

Hey Brian, just a little humor. My point was you may as well have been talking about yourself. I'm positive that 99% of the people here would agree with me that your word is more than good enough. I don't need anymore confirmation than that. Imho you wouldn't share info that you don't honestly believe would help a person play better golf. Real TEACHING from a Real INSTRUCTOR!! Thanks for all the info you guys share!!
 
Last edited:
From that angle its very hard to see with the left wrist is doing, I see it rotating more than anything until its well past impact.

You don't have to see what the left wrist is doing... Tiger's right wrist is bowing. Put your hands on the club and bow your right wrist... now look at your left wrist. :rolleyes:

Here's another...

 
You don't have to see what the left wrist is doing... Tiger's right wrist is bowing. Put your hands on the club and bow your right wrist... now look at your left wrist. :rolleyes:

Here's another...


If I do not rotate the arm I agree with you, it bends dramatically, but in the plane of a golf swing its only fractionally bending due to the left arm rotation. I believe it does bend a little and but maybe not a lot. Thats what I dont understand in the arch graph, with no coordinates is going from arch-bent .00001 change or 25 degrees.
 

btp

New
I can see the tumble/rotation blend. I assume the design of the club and weighting with the plane counteracts the ability to do a pure tumble on full swings at tour speeds.
 
If I do not rotate the arm I agree with you, it bends dramatically, but in the plane of a golf swing its only fractionally bending due to the left arm rotation. I believe it does bend a little and but maybe not a lot. Thats what I dont understand in the arch graph, with no coordinates is going from arch-bent .00001 change or 25 degrees.

It is still going from arched to bent even if the change is .00001 degrees, no? And even that small amount of change in the left wrist will result in how much of a change in the clubhead 35-40 something inches away? And what does the opposite do?
 
Thank goodness we are getting somewhere. Threads of this
712657d1337394705-need-some-help-identifying-watch-what-gen-seamaster-thanks-point_over_your_head.jpg
nature were getting pretty old.

Oh, just relax.....let there be some constructive thinking, or ........we all can just nod our heads all the time (or maybe you can :)
 

jimmyt

New
Originally Posted by mjh116
Brian, are you talking while standing in front of a mirror again!??! Lol

No.


This is a very respected teacher outside of our group who has capture many PGA Tour players on his AMM/12 sensor system.


Brian,

I think he was making a joke.......your so focused on this topic you may have missed his attempt at humor......it was actually funny
 
No.


This is a very respected teacher outside of our group who has capture many PGA Tour players on his AMM/12 sensor system.

Brian, are you talking while standing in front of a mirror again!??! Lol

Brian,

I think he was making a joke.......your so focused on this topic you may have missed his attempt at humor......it was actually funny

Right on jimmyt! Those were my intentions!! Thanks!!!
 

Brian Manzella

Administrator
I hope ya'll appreciate this graphic.

Three hours of work.

Getting in touch with the teacher while in flight....30 minutes of work.

Many answers in between.....

The last thread of its kind on the free site—pay site launches Monday.
 
Something that may be lost with this wrist movement discussion are the forces being applied on the club at the transition and start down as well as the pivot sequencing need to set up these wrist movements so as to not bend or extend the left wrist too early. These parts of the motions are still a connection to the larger swing.
 

Brian Manzella

Administrator
Look at how much roll!!!!

Sorry Charlie, now close-to-open here....massive roll of the left forearm from a golfer RENOWN for a low rotation swing.
 
Oh, just relax.....let there be some constructive thinking, or ........we all can just nod our heads all the time (or maybe you can :)

I've engaged in many debates and asked and attempted to answer many questions on here. I just don't see the point in trying to explain something to someone when it is virtually against their religion to accept it as reality. It's been proven in 3-D and he's going to refute it in 2-D, again and again.

I am all for constructive thinking. But when you willfully ignore all the evidence (aka the proof) that you are wrong in order to hold on to a concept that nobody on tour is doing, except in 2-D, it makes some of these threads go in pointless circles for far too long.

Can't wait for Monday!
 

jimmyt

New
The last thread of its kind on the free site—pay site launches Monday


I have follwed you on this site for over 4 years, how will I continue to do so starting Monday.

How do I gain access, fees!, etc. Please provide details
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top